Tobacco Asia

72 tobaccoasia Issue 1, 2025 January / February Korean government has imposed stricter regulations on vaping products. E- cigarettes are taxed at a higher rate than HTP, and there are concerns about their potential health risks. The South Korean government has issued state- ments acknowledging that while HTP are a less harmful alternative to smok- ing, the long-term effects of e-cigarettes remain uncertain. This caution has slowed the widespread adoption of e-cigarettes in South Korea, but the mar- ket for HTP continues to grow. One of the challenges facing South Korea in the realm of THR is the strong tobacco control framework already in place. Smoking rates have been declining in the country, and the government has been focused on reduc- ing tobacco use through traditional means, such as smoking bans and public education campaigns. As a result, the adoption of new tobacco products, par- ticularly e-cigarettes, has faced resistance from both public health authorities and the general public. China: the slow adoption of harm reduction In China, the adoption of THR strategies has been slower compared to Japan and South Korea. While the Chinese government has taken steps to regu- late e-cigarettes and other alternative products, the tobacco industry remains deeply entrenched in the country. China National Tobacco Corporation (CNTC), a state-owned entity, continues to dominate the market, and there has been limited public health messaging around the benefits of alternatives like e-cigarettes and HTPs. China's regulatory approach to THR has been cautious. In 2019, the government introduced restrictions on the sale of flavored e-liquids, a move that was seen as an effort to curb the popularity of vaping products. However, there is a growing market for e-cigarettes in China's urban centers, where consumers are increasingly aware of the potential benefits of switching from combustible cigarettes to reduced risk products. India and Indonesia: regulatory hurdles and market resistance In contrast to Japan and South Korea, India and Indonesia have faced signifi- cant challenges in adopting THR strategies. In India, the government took a firm stance against e-cigarettes, banning their sale in 2019. The government's decision was based on concerns about the health risks of vaping, despite evi- dence suggesting that e-cigarettes are less harmful than traditional cigarettes. The ban has prevented the widespread availability of e-cigarettes and other alternative products, slowing the adoption of THR strategies. Similarly, Indonesia, where smoking rates are among the highest in the world, has shown limited interest in THR. While e-cigarettes and HTP are available in certain urban areas, there is little regulatory support for these products, and public health messaging remains focused on traditional tobacco control methods. The dominance of traditional cigarettes, particularly clove- based kretek cigarettes, presents a significant barrier to the widespread adop- tion of alternative tobacco products. In both India and Indonesia, the regulatory environments for THR are still in their infancy. Public health authorities are primarily focused on reduc- ing smoking through traditional methods, and there is limited interest in ex- ploring reduced-risk alternatives. However, as the global conversation around tobacco harm reduction continues to evolve, there may be room for change in these countries, particularly if public demand for alternatives grows. THR in other parts of Southeast Asia Thailand has historically taken a strict stance on tobacco control, implement- ing measures such as high taxes, advertising restrictions, and strong public smoking bans. The country has been recognized for its aggressive anti-smok- ing campaigns. However, when it comes to THR, Thailand's position has been cautious. The government banned e-cigarettes in 2014, citing concerns over their safety and the potential risks of unknown health effects. Vietnam presents a unique case in the context of THR. Smoking rates are high, particularly among men. The government has enacted several tobacco control measures, such as tobacco taxation, adver- tising restrictions, and public smoking bans. While these measures have contributed to gradual declines in smoking prevalence, the introduction of THR strategies such as e-cigarettes and HTP has been less receptive. In 2019, the Vietnamese government imposed a ban on e-cigarettes, citing concerns over public health risks and the popularity of vaping among young people. The ban includes both the sale and import of e-cigarettes and related products, with penalties for those found in violation. Similar- ly, in 2020, In 2020, the government officially pro- hibited the sale and import of HTP. Despite these bans, the illegal market for these products continues to persist in the country. The Philippines is one of the more progres- sive countries in Southeast Asia when it comes to THR. In recent years, the government has rec- ognized the potential benefits of alternatives to smoking, such as e-cigarettes and HTP. In 2020, the Philippines passed a law that legalized the sale of these products, implementing regulations to en- sure their safety and quality. The law allows for the regulation of e-cigarettes and HTP and provides a framework for their sale and distribution. This shift toward harm reduction is part of a broader strategy to reduce smoking-related health risks while providing alternatives to traditional to- bacco use. While e-cigarettes and HTP remain niche products in the Philippine market, the government has expressed interest in further expanding access to these alternatives as part of a wider tobacco con- trol policy. Public health officials continue to moni- tor the effectiveness of these products, and there is a growing recognition of the role they can play in helping smokers quit or reduce their harm. In response to the growing demand for al- ternatives to smoking, Malaysia has taken a more proactive approach to THR in recent years. The government has introduced regulations for the sale of e-cigarettes and vaping products, including a sales ban to individuals under eighteen. While there is still some skepticism surrounding e-ciga- rettes and vaping, particularly regarding their long- term health effects, Malaysia is exploring their role in THR as part of its broader strategy to address smoking-related harm. The future of tobacco harm reduction in Asia will depend largely on the actions of govern- ments, public health organizations, and the tobac- co industry. While countries like Japan and South Korea have made significant progress in adopting alternative products, many other nations in the region remain cautious. The challenge moving forward will be finding a balance between public health goals, regulatory frameworks, and the inter- ests of the tobacco industry.

• Cover