Key Milwaukee

March 2026

An A-Z visitors guide to Milwaukee Wisconsin. Sponsored by Key Magazine Milwaukee, Wisconsin

Issue link: https://read.dmtmag.com/i/1543463

Contents of this Issue

Navigation

Page 39 of 47

40 keymilwaukee.com 2 3 Joey Gerard's – A Bartolotta Supper Club 1 Hollywood-style supper club brings traditional favorites, including charcoal-fired steaks and grilled lobster tails as well as traditional cocktails including the Old Fashioned, Sloe Gin Fizz and Singapore Sling. 5601 Broad St. Greendale Buckatabon Supper Club 2 Known for its nostalgic and entertaining Northwoods and supper club experience with three cozy Northwoods Shanties. 7700 Harwood Ave. Wauwatosa Dobie's Restaurant and Lounge 3 Opened as a custard stand in 1954. Now this classic Wisconsin supper club serves perfectly muddled hand-craft - ed cocktails and a lazy Susan relish tray including homemade cheese spread or liver pate, pickled beets, corn and sweet pickle relish and Swedish meatballs. 4136 S Kinnickinnic Ave. St. Francis Hobnob Restaurant 4 Located between Kenosha and Racine, overlooking Lake Michigan. Established in 1954, the Hobnob has the ambi - ance of the classic Wisconsin Supper Club. 277 S. Sheridan Rd. Racine The P acking House 5 Family owned since 1974, the supper club-style restaurant is a regular haunt for local resi - dents with live-music Fridays and Saturdays. 900 E. Layton A ve. South Side Five O'Clock Steakhouse 6 Serves supper club staples like the relish tray, fresh salads and premium steaks since 1946. The Alley Cat Lounge features cocktails in a 1940s retro-lounge ambiance. Enjoy live music most weekend nights with no cover charge. Travel & Leisure described this steakhouse as a "classic supper club setting with a Mad Men vibe." 2416 W. State St. West Side Silver Lake Country Inn Offers a unique and comfort - able place to dine at affordable prices. 5602 Peters Dr. West Bend Wallace Lake Supper Club Presents an eclectic ambiance of Midcentury Modern, knotty pine, and lakeshore. 2472 Wallace Lake Rd. West Bend Great Eats and Retro Style at W I S C O N S I N S U P P E R C L U B S A throwback from the past, these establishments offer classic steak and seafood options in a cozy yet upscale environment. 3 2 food 3 2 1

Articles in this issue

Links on this page

Archives of this issue

view archives of Key Milwaukee - March 2026