Key Milwaukee

April 2026

An A-Z visitors guide to Milwaukee Wisconsin. Sponsored by Key Magazine Milwaukee, Wisconsin

Issue link: https://read.dmtmag.com/i/1544081

Contents of this Issue

Navigation

Page 39 of 47

40 keymilwaukee.com 2 3 St. Paul Fish Company If there's one place in town that knows fish, it's St. Paul Fish Company. Choose from Schlitz battered cod or shrimp, grouper, walleye or catfish paired with fries and coleslaw. Or treat yourself to a live Maine lobster dinner. Milwaukee Public Market & Mequon Public Market Lakefront Brewery 1 This spacious brewpub offers a wide variety of fish fry options including cod, walleye, shrimp and plant-based fish fry. Enjoy family style seating and polka music. 1872 N. Commerce St.. Brewer's Hill The Swingin' Door Exchange With a cozy tavern feel, a nearly 100-year-old bar pouring clas- sic cocktails and a crowd that feels like old friends, this is the kind of place where Friday fish fry can make any traveler feel like a local. 219 E Michigan St Downtown Buckatabon Supper Club 2 Known for its nostalgic and entertaining Northwoods and supper club experience with three cozy Northwoods Shanties, offers specialty fish fry featuring haddock, perch or pan-fried walleye. 7700 Harwood Ave. Wauwatosa Twisted Fisherman Crab Shack 3 Features fried cod with fries, coleslaw, rye, butter and lemon. Additional seafood options available. 1200 W. Canal St. Menomonee Valley The Packing House 4 Family owned since 1974, the supper club-style restaurant has hand-breaded fried cod served with house-made cole- slaw, tartar sauce, rye bread and fries. If you can't stay and dine in, pick up fish fries through the drive-through. 900 E. Layton Ave. South Side Kegel's Inn 5 This historic, family-owned beer hall and beer garden in West Allis is famous for its award-winning fish fry options including hand-breaded cod, perch, bluegill, walleye, grouper, catfish, jumbo shrimp or vegan fishless filets all served in a warm, historic setting with hand-painted murals. 5901 W. National Ave. West Allis Motor Bar & Restaurant Enjoy three pieces of beer- battered cod, served with fries, house jicama slaw, cornbread muffin and tartar sauce. 400 W. Canal St. Menomonee Valley Joey Gerard's - A Bartolotta Supper Club 6 Brings a touch of old-school supper club charm to its be- loved fish fry, served in a cozy, retro-inspired dining room with leather booths, warm lighting and a classic Wisconsin feel. 5601 Broad St. Greendale Friday Night Tradition: M I LW A U K E E F I S H F R I E S From neighborhood taverns to supper clubs, Milwaukee serves up some of the Midwest's best fish fries. 3 2 food 3 1 2

Articles in this issue

Links on this page

Archives of this issue

view archives of Key Milwaukee - April 2026