IDA Universal

November/December 2014

Issue link: https://read.dmtmag.com/i/430655

Contents of this Issue

Navigation

Page 75 of 83

I DA U N I V E R S A L N ove m b e r - D e ce m b e r 2 0 1 4 76 LEGAL LINE Continued from page 11 and the unique confi gura- tion of a "non-sealing" part of the gasket. e solution was, fortunately, simple. Don't use the (costly and complex) manufacturing process and change the "pattern," so that the patented design is not used. In each of the above situations, varying degrees of due diligence were under- taken with mixed results. e object lesson, however, is that when committing money and resources to start a new product line, don't skimp on the due diligence. is is even more important in remanu- facturing an OEM-created product. As I have cautioned many times, OEMs are patent happy. ey have the money to spend on patents and copyrights and are justifi ably cautious. Why spend millions on a product and have it knocked off as soon as it hits the market? is brings us to "How can you fi nd out?" before you start to spend product development money. e fi rst step is the easiest: get an OEM sample, and if the product is also sold by the OEM's Tier suppliers, get a sample of that, as well. Carefully inspect the sample, the packaging and any written information or DVD supplied with the original part and package. If you fi nd patent numbers, patents pending, copyrights or similar informa- tion, stop there and plan to investigate further. If any of the foregoing are present, seek advice from a patent profes- sional that is experienced in the technology and can fully advise you. Patents are written in a language that only faintly resembles English, so don't try to translate the patent and the technology "protected" and miss something. If none of the above is present, the next step is, again, to seek professional help. A search by "category," "patent holder," or "function" in patent public records is reasonably likely to uncover relevant patents that might prevent your project from taking off or may enable you to fi nd a second source of a needed part or component that will be integrated into your remanu- factured product. With the foregoing in mind, what are the practical limits of remanufacturing a product? First, if there are patented parts or major assemblies, they can be re-used. is can include re-machining, adding metal and re-machining, inserting sleeves or spacers, coating or treating, and similar techniques. e fi rst buyer "bought" the patent rights, and bringing a component or assembly back to OEM speci- fi cations by manufacturing processes is permitted without infringement. e next level may be making actual 100 percent new replacements for certain components. Again, make sure that, at the compo- nent level, no patent protection prohibits a new part being made and used. In some instances, the only solution may be to obtain a replacement part or compo- nent from the OEM or Tier supplier and integrate that into your remanufactured product. e problem then arises when the OEM or Tier supplies dry up. What next? In this situation, it may be appropriate to re-design other parts of the system or compo- nents to accept a non-patented part which you create on your own. Again, this type of path requires the assistance of a patent professional. It is incredibly easy to misunder- stand some arcane description or claim in a patent and truly believe your work-around will not infringe, but this is a dangerous path and can be very costly. Another common mistake is to blindly buy-in parts or components from outside suppliers. Even in the case of OEM Tier suppliers, they may be contractually prohibited from selling parts to you by the OEM or a higher Tier. us, your entire rebuilt product is at risk if you use prohibited parts. Also, do not trust a supplier. Just because they are selling something, does not make it legal or protect you if you use the part or product. e supplier may not have done its homework on patents, it may have done it wrong, or it may (suppliers from non-patent countries) simply not care. eir problem becomes your problem and you have a dual problem: you have infringed and are taken to task, and your supplier's ignorance or lack of care is not a viable defense. Additionally, a real risk lies in making decisions about OEM or Tier 1 rights that are incorrect. By the time you commit to engineering, tooling, producing and selling a few hundred or thousand products, the arrival of the lawyer letter accusing you of infringing makes the situa- tion very real and personal. It brings your customers into the mix, as well, as any prohibition on selling applies to them, too. is is not to say that an accusation of infringement is a death knell. In many instances, the homework was done right and the patent holder can be convinced that there is indeed no infringe- ment, and the situation goes away with minimal secondary expense. If the patent holder wants to fi ght, and you are convinced they are wrong, then "game on" if the stakes are high enough for you. Because, in every patent case, the patent holder risks the court fi nding the patent invalid or unenforceable – not a good day in court. What is the lesson here? Simply put, you can, with reasonable assurance, reman u- factur' any patented part, componen, or assembly, as long as you do not materially change the product from the original design and specifi - cation, or replicate a part or assembly with a new part that infringes. Howeve , in most case, where the investment will be signifi cant (including your reputation), it makes sense to get advice u front to make sure you are not going to be surprised with an accusation of infringement that will cost far more to clean up than doing it the right way the fi rst time. ●

Articles in this issue

Archives of this issue

view archives of IDA Universal - November/December 2014