Issue link: https://read.dmtmag.com/i/674548
I DA U N I V E R S A L M ay -J u n e 2 0 1 6 52 LEGAL LINE Continued from page 11 Hardest and most expen- sive to make are the 3-D metal parts. Two leading technolo- gies are spatter-spraying and sintering. e fi rst is like an inkjet printer that uses vapor- ized metal for its "ink," and the latter partly fuses metal powder that is then furnace sintered. In these applications, the hardware "builds" the part in 30-100 micron layers, line b y line with a laser or similar device. e applications are limited now only by imagina- tion and budget: turbine and compressor wheels for turbos, super-long-wearing fuel injec- tion parts, valve train parts, hydraulic valves, pump parts, wear parts, even entire pistons. And, as a bonus, the most intricate parts can be made, o en without any machining at all, to incredibly close toler- ances. Long lines of workers on machines with pensions, days off , personal problems, wages and benefi t demands, turnover and the like, stand aside for lines of humming printers that work 7/24/365, with only limited human intervention. e rub is that 3-D is slow, a few microns at a time. Grass grows and paint dries faster, and unless you are making "$10,000 toilet seat" aerospace parts or medical devices, the process is not presently adapt- able to the mass production model for engine and equip- ment parts and components. Nonetheless, as speed, fl exibility, and new "printing ink" becomes available, the potential uses of 3-D start to nibble at the short run and specialized parts of our world – the guts for 50 turbos for older, but still useful, engines, 400 sets of internal parts for injectors or pumps – and if otherwise unavailable, pricing can be aggressive. Basically, the rule now is if you can draw it, you can make it, but don't ask for a lot of units or low cost. To put it simply, we are on the leading edge of a manufac- turing revolution as important as making identical and truly interchangeable parts from metal, and this leads to the "legal" issues that must be faced. First, backing up, there are three types of intellectual property protection: a utility patent that describes a physical device and its uses, a method patent that describes the method by which something is made, and a design patent that simply protects the shape of an object but not its use or method of manufacture. Conventionally, it is o en an objective in a patent to protect both the device and the way it is made. is gets tricky and is o en misunder- stood. For example, a gasket maker owns a utility patent on a gasket that has specially spaced holes that do nothing more than hold the pushrods straight up in a precise location to expedite OEM assembly methods. e same company also has a method patent on how it assembles the metal and carbon fi ber sheets and fi nishes the lamination of the gasket. If it makes and sells a gasket with the "special holes," using the "special recipe" for manufacturing, both must be avoided to provide an a ermarket gasket that does not infringe. is puts us at the fence around the patent minefi eld that is emerging with the new technology. To understand this issue, fi rst we have to know that over 60 percent of the patents fi led today are so ware or chemical/pharmaceutical patents that seek to patent the un-seeable. In this context, we fi nd the 3-D world. Obviously, if a better 3-D printing machine is invented, that is patentable, but what if the machine uses unique so ware? at, too, is patentable under many circumstances. Next, is the way the machine prints and/or the material it uses patentable? Probably, but is what the machine actually makes patentable? e answer to each of the above questions is a clear legal one: yes and no. As we can see, we are getting into some high weeds here, when a mix of technology, so ware, materials, processes, and the design of a particular part come together in a blender full of patent opportunities and risks. For example, buying a 3-D printing system may bring patents that prevent making the machine yourself and selling it – likely not a problem. Next, can you use the embedded so ware to use the machine? Probably, like a so ware license for a PC, but can you replicate the so ware or export it to a vendor to make your parts on another machine or by someone else? Maybe. Further, if you use the "recommended" resin or other raw material, you may be okay, but what are other implications of the combina- tion of machine, so ware, raw material and so on? What are your restraints on combina- tions and innovation? Turning next to "what you make"…are there patents on the device? For example, if you make a fuel injector part that is patented to be made in steel, with a particular set of specifi cations for fi nish, and, say, heat treatment or coating, will you infringe on that patent if you skip the material and process parts of the existing patent and make the part "fi nished for installation" in sintered metal, by a highly precise 3-D printing machine? e opportunities abound: a patented investment cast turbo impeller can be made of 3-D deposited sintered metal. Does it infringe or not? ere are relatively safe paths for now: having a 3-D specialist vendor make proto- types and short-run parts, leaving only the patent issues of the actual part for consid- eration, using 3-D to make new and unique parts, or, venturing closer to the edge, making existing and possibly patented parts with process or material parts of the patent, with a new process and a diff erent material. In summing up this situa- tion, this is another example where looking before you leap is the best course. Rapidly expanding availability of 3-D

