Issue link: https://read.dmtmag.com/i/703077
I DA U N I V E R S A L J u l y -Au g u s t 2 0 1 6 56 LEGAL LINE Continued from page 13 Robert McIntyre Wegman, Hessler and Vanderburg 6055 Rockside Woods Blvd. Suite 200 Independence, Ohio 44131 Phone 01.216.642.3342 (Offi ce) 01.216.403.0516 (Cell) e.mail: RWMcintyre@wegmanlaw.com has been invalidated by the patent offi ce four times has preserved the presumptive legal monopoly of the tooling system for what could be seven or more years. In this context, we again can turn to the method and machine conundrum and how it can aff ect both the manufacturer and the "copier." Let's use an example closer to home: a head gasket for a high horsepower diesel. In this situation, between the 40+ psi boost and 25,000 psi + injection pressures, peak cylinder pressures routinely hit 300bar+, a tough place for the head gasket. In response, engine OEMs, general engine parts manufacturers and specialized manufacturers have used steel, copper, carbon fi ber matrix, gas-fi lled sealing rings, and so on, each claiming their special sauce prevents head gasket failure. is has led to some patents, but due to the cross-fertilization between automotive and heavy duty applications, the technology is substantially in the public domain. On this heavily populated stage, a Tier 1 supplier does invent a generally superior head gasket design and, a er testing, starts spreading it across the OEM and a er- market spectrum. It is popular and profi table, so the manufacturer wants to recoup its R&D and capture 100 percent market share, not by being a better mousetrap, but by monopolizing a patent. e patent lawyer gives the bad news: your super-gasket is merely a clever and eff ec- tive combination of concepts and hardware in the public domain and will not pass the smell test at the patent offi ce. What to do? e lawyer says, "Aha! We will patent your gasket lamination process and not only block its use, but also scare most of the a er- market competition by simply calling the gasket "patented." Nobody will take the chance of infringement, and the market is ours." is assumes that compet- itors don't have lawyers and can't make gaskets that are the same. is is an easy one. e highly successful gasket design and its manufacturing method patent are public record, and, right off the start, it is obvious that the painstakingly designed and tested gasket IS NOT PATENTED, thus free to copy as needed. Second, now the process that makes the gasket work and easy to make is exposed and subject to every reverse engineer and manufac- turing expert in the world. In this real-life example, a successful company not only gave away the store by limiting its patent to the manufac- turing processes it developed and uses, but also exposed their innovative, complex and tricky process to the competition for their copying pleasure. e result was that similarly situated competitors copied the design and fi gured out a way to make it around the patent, and less ethical competitors here and abroad simply copied everything and took a chance on a court visit. What are the take-aways here? First, patents should be carefully examined to determine if they are method, device, or both before looking at reverse engineering, so that resources are applied in the right place to produce a high quality replacement counterpart without expecting a "lawyer letter" from a patent owner. Second, spend the money up front to avoid paying legal fees on the 7-10 year plan, while excluded from a lucrative market by endless legal proceedings. ●

