IDA Universal

May/June 2017

Issue link: https://read.dmtmag.com/i/820377

Contents of this Issue

Navigation

Page 13 of 55

I DA U N I V E R S A L M ay -J u n e 2 0 1 7 14 LEGAL LINE Continued from page 11 Robert McIntyre Wegman, Hessler and Vanderburg 6055 Rockside Woods Blvd. Suite 200 Independence, Ohio 44131 Phone 01.216.642.3342 (Offi ce) 01.216.403.0516 (Cell) e.mail: RWMcintyre@wegmanlaw.com GET, and other higher-value products, inquiries made to many aspiring vendors about clearly infringing products invariably elicited a very confi - dent, "Our products do not violate any patents. ey are all our original engineering and design." at's as nonsen- sical as pictures of fi ctitious manufacturing plants. As a simple gut-check, I compared my last Con-Expo exhibitor list to the 2017 list, and only about 10 percent of the start-up competitors made it three years. With all the above in mind, on the big stage of OEM and Tier 1 suppliers, the contrast and risk to our members becomes more immediate. e express-train rush by the OEMs to incorpo- rate more and more sophis- tication into their products, the downsizing of engines and ancillaries, and everything working substantially harder, faster and hotter to save fuel, cut emissions and reduce noise materially raises the bar for the a ermarket. A piston that might work well in a 15-liter "legacy" engine with 400 horsepower is marginal at best in a seven-liter Tier 4 engine making the same power. e mature a ermarket knows this and expends substantial resources to be able to honestly off er an OEM-quality product. e emerging competitor simply makes it look the same and leaves it at that, knowing th at in many situa- tions, price sells. is situation is not unlike earlier days of the IDA, where OEM products were not that complex, sophisticated or hard to reverse engineer. Any competent company could make equivalent products and sell them at competitive prices. is is not today's world, but the same techniques for penetrating the market are still being used, and now to the detriment of the mature a ermarket. is is a serious dilemma for the IDA and its members. Do we insist on extreme vetting of new members to somehow qualify their business intentions and product quality? Do we try to educate them on the etiquette of quality, or do we simply let the market determine the survival of the fi ttest? No approach is foolproof, and no successes are guaranteed. However, now that the shoe is on the other foot for the mature a ermarket, a trend toward less substantial compa- nies and products can only dilute the hard-won reputation of today's a ermarket. If the above is not enough, appreciate that emerging markets today are still "legacy" markets. is is recognized by OEMs, like Cat, Cummins and others that now off er products and parts not salable in developed areas. However, the "legacy" is catching up. Machines and non-Tier prime movers that are still in vogue in some areas will not be sold there in the foresee- able future. Simply put, the mature a ermarket must go Mach 3 to keep up with the OEMs. On the other hand, it must compete on price with the up-and-coming, emerging companies in their home markets and, increasingly, in mature markets as well. I always like to close my articles with a lesson on succeeding forward. is time, it's not so simple. If there is a lesson to be learned, it is to stay the course. Dropping down to wrestle with the emerging competition is sorely tempting, but abandoning core values to compete on price or other terms is not even a viable short-term solution. It also appears that profi ts are more easily realized with high-quality products backed by solid companies. Going to the price and quality basement simply to pump cash fl ow is a dead-end street. ●

Articles in this issue

Links on this page

Archives of this issue

view archives of IDA Universal - May/June 2017