Issue link: https://read.dmtmag.com/i/820377
I DA U N I V E R S A L M ay -J u n e 2 0 1 7 11 LEGAL LINE Robert W. McIntyre IDA Association Legal Counsel Continued on page 14 I was fortunate enough to have a couple of days avail- able a er the mid-year Board meeting to walk Con-Expo to see what was new in our industry. I was particu- larly impressed by our members' booths, which starkly contrasted with many emerging competitors from lesser developed markets in other areas of the world. e takeaway from this experience was simply that our members have "arrived" and are positioned, not as secondary alternatives, but as genuine head- to-head OEM competition. is is worlds apart from "will fi t" past perceptions and portrayal of the a ermarket by OEMs as unques- tionably inferior. Needless to say, this transformation was driven, in part, by the OEMs sourcing production and dealer stock parts and assemblies from the very same "will fi t" companies that now comprise substantial parts of the a ermarket, as well. However, the myth persists – as if repetition by the OEMs could make it true – that the track chain, rubber track, engine parts, pumps and so on "bought in" from what are also a ermarket suppliers and put on machine dealer shelves are somehow diff erent or better than the parts that shared the production lines with the OEMs' orders. e second takeaway for this comparison is that the lesser known (and in fact, essentially unknown) competitors following in the footsteps of established companies not only have an easier time accessing customers, Trending at Vegas but also benefi t by having the hard work of reverse engineering done free by mature a ermarket players. is is especially evident when looking at what might be considered less sophisticated products, such as GET or under- carriage, but which increasingly permeate into gaskets, seals, engine and hydraulic parts, etc. Unfortunately, what appear to be good looking parts from what appears to be a nice-looking, well established factory may not be as good as they seem. First, making any true OEM-quality replacement part is very diffi cult, even if a company organizes the manufac- ture by vendors. Materials, processes, specifi cations and key engineering elements are not there by accident, but are the r of sound application of scientifi c knowledge, as well as time- consuming and costly testing. Our members have pulled themselves up by their bootstraps the hard way, investing tens of millions of dollars to achieve genuine, provable OEM equiva- lency. If not such a serious matter, it would almost be funny that many "exhibitors" with good looking parts and glossy photos of shiny, new factories in idyllic settings were simply fabrications. In some instances, the same locations and "factory" images were used by several diff erent exhibitors under diff erent names. At least, they were savvy enough not to share booths or have adjacent booths. Google any parts group, and you will be amazed by the number of companies off ering the parts. Drilling down to actual names and addresses on Google Earth, however, o en reveals something entirely diff erent. In one instance, an aspiring exhibitor had simply bought genuine OEM and other parts from established a ermarket sources, ground off the part numbers and trademarks and off ered them as samples of products that would be shipped from "their factory" in a lower cost country. is could lead to the well-worn cautionary tale: " e samples looked great, the fi rst container had too many QC fails, and when we complained, the third container never arrived." is is not an indictment of aspiring vendors; everyone had to start somewhere. What is concerning is that many newcomers do not seem inter- ested in doing it the old fashioned way, but instead just make a fast buck while the sun shines, with incredibly low prices and no worries about the future. Having some knowledge of "who's who" with respect to patent protection in engine parts,

