IDA Universal

September/October 2012

Issue link: https://read.dmtmag.com/i/81895

Contents of this Issue

Navigation

Page 55 of 69

LEGAL LINE Continued from page 23 quence: the alleged infringing company fought back and won the lawsuit. Th is is doubly important, because there are several ways to defend a patent infringement lawsuit. Th e most useful are: 1. Prove that your prod- ucts simply don't infringe, and therefore, there is no reason to "cease and desist." 2. Prove that the patent is not valid, because it was already patented by someone else. 3. Prove that you made and sold your products before the patent was actually applied for, and therefore, the patent is invalid. It is the last defense that was successfully used by the target in this lawsuit, which also illustrates the fundamental risk in starting a patent fi ght - especially where the pre- lawsuit homework was not as good as it should have been. Stepping back for a moment, patent infringement lawsuits are no diff erent than James Bond sitting down at the table. You are "all in" when you sit down. How does this work? It's very simple. When the defense to the patent infringement lawsuit is based on the "target" making the products before the patent application is fi led, and the target can prove this, the patent is dead forever. Th is is not limited to the patent holder and only this target; it permanently invalidates the patent for everybody in the 56 entire world. Th erefore, all of your competitors now can produce your products and eat you for breakfast, lunch and dinner, forever. So, what started out as a simple search and destroy mission against a presumably soſt and weak target turned into a complete disaster that included six-fi gure legal fees and the complete destruc- tion of the patent forever. Th is situation was made even worse since the target off ered to settle the case on reasonable com- mercial terms aſt er the federal court found the patent invalid, but the patent holder was not budging. Th e patent holder expected to be vindicated by an appeal to the next higher court and the target to be taught a lesson about patent law. Unfortunately, the odds were even worse in the appeal court, with less than a 10 percent reversal record, the inevitable happened. Again, the patent was found to be completely invalid. In no time at all, the entire industry became aware of the situation, and competi- tion started to rev up in a very hot customer market. In this unfortunate tale, the lessons for businesses that want to protect their rights in a valuable product or product line with a patent are: 1. Measure three times, and check your work a fourth time before making and during the prosecution of a patent application. It is far better to tell the patent offi ce everything about the "prior art" and earlier patents and to fi ght your fi ght there, instead of walking into a courtroom and fi nding out in front of an unsympathetic judge that your patent is not worth the paper it is written on. 2. Patent infringement law- suits are like any lawsuit: don't fi le it unless you can prove it and win. Th ere is an impor- tant distinction: facts do win lawsuits, but if they're not in a form that gets into evidence, you lose. 3. Be fully aware that by suing for infringement, you are "all in" like James Bond. An adverse fi nding that your patent is invalid makes for a very bad day and every day aſt erwards. 4. Don't base your strat- egy on future help from any appeals court. In most, the reversal rate is in the lower double digits, and in the one federal court that hears patent appeals, the reversal rate is in the single digits. Making a record is best leſt for rock stars; it has poor value in litigation. 5. Figure out ahead of time where you really want to end up. As one company found out, the "law of unintended consequences" takes precedent over patent law, and the result was the destruction of the most valuable thing the company had - its patent. Th is article is not meant to discourage patent fi lings or suing to enforce rights. It's about the dark side of what can happen unless thorough preparation and research are undertaken and completed before applying for a pat- ent, during the application process, and if and when a lawsuit is fi led to enforce those patent rights. If one key element is missing or incomplete, no court or appeals court is likely to fi x the problem. Just like every other recommendation I have made for the last (?) years in these pages, spend the money and do it right or pay the unintended consequences. ● Robert McIntyre Wegman, Hessler and Vanderburg 6055 Rockside Woods Blvd. Suite 200 Independence, Ohio 44131 Phone 01.216.642.3342 (offi ce) 01.216.403.0516 (Cell) e.mail RWMcintyre@wegmanlaw.com IDA UNIVERSAL September-October 2012

Articles in this issue

Links on this page

Archives of this issue

view archives of IDA Universal - September/October 2012