Issue link: http://read.dmtmag.com/i/814629
Corrosion Preventives Technical Training and Reference Info Metalworking Technical Training 1 800 255 4417 www.castrol.com/GPS March 2017 Length of Protection Humidity Cabinet notes: The humidity cabinet test is the most common, as most inhibitors are sold for short- to medium-term protection. However, when investigating the humidity cabinet performance, it is important to understand that some standards are variants of the ASTM D1748 method, which specifies "high" humidity at 120° F. Other specifications may call for ASTM D2247-68, which is 100% humidity at 100° F. Some customers have standards based on 80% humidity, or a variable humidity, perhaps cycling between 80% humidity and 100% humidity. Some tests have variable temperatures, rather than a constant 100° F. However the 100%/100° F test is severe. The constant 100% humidity deposits condensate onto the panel's surface and provides a washing action that challenges the rust preventive film. The value of the severe standard is that it accelerates the time to reach failure, with the downside of not replicating the "real world" very well. Salt Spray notes: Salt spray chamber tests are much more severe than humidity cabinet tests, and have the most value if protection is needed in a marine environment. It duplicates the harsh on-ocean or shore line environment. Some users specify a good showing in a salt spray environment as a measure of general outdoor protection. Overall Concerns About Reliance on Benchmarking Tests Understanding an inhibitor's protective properties is obviously important; however, there is some subjectivity in the tests. In addition, they aren't always repeatable or reproducible. Most humidity cabinet tests will use two test panels subjected to the same preparation, both coated in the same rust preventive and allowed to dry in a vertical hanging position before being placed in the hood of the humidity cabinet. Most often, the two test panels will not fail at the exact same time (repeatability). The same fluid being tested in two different labs also typically does not achieve the same length of protection (reproducibility). Given this subjectivity, it is not completely possible to use cabinet test results to compare two products/test results with great confidence. For example, comparing product A, tested in March and April, at Lab X, giving a passing average of 48 days, with product B, tested in July and August, at Lab Y, which yielded a passing average of 55 days. The only way to compare two different inhibitors with accuracy is to start their testing simultaneously in the same humidity cabinet. It is better to test multiple test panels of each to help buffer any variability in the panels. Salt spray cabinet results have a similar potential for variability, though due to the severity of the testing, it is not likely that a fluid that failed at 12 hours will suddenly pass a 50 hour test. Again, if a comparison of two inhibitors is sought, test them side by side in the same cabinet at the same time to have the most confidence in the results. Categories of Protection Typical categories of protection are: • Short-term — In-process — Final • Medium- to Long-term — Workpieces ready for assembly — Finished assemblies Additionally: • Indoor protection • Outdoor protection Q44

